THE (SECRET) RULES OF 'AUDIO REVIEWING'

Post Reply

Topic author
Ruben Vargas
Posts: 592
Joined: 26 Jan 2011 07:19
Equipos: M-Audio Fast Track Ultra, KRK Rockit 6
Contact:

THE (SECRET) RULES OF 'AUDIO REVIEWING'

#1

Post by Ruben Vargas » 21 Sep 2013 06:48

Fragmento tomado de la siguiente pagina:

http://www.high-endaudio.com/RR-STEREOPHILE.html#WP5


THE (SECRET) RULES OF 'AUDIO REVIEWING'

1. Never anger any protected audio industry entity, such as:

A. An important current, or potential, advertiser; including manufacturers, distributors or retailers, or...

B. Any other audio establishment which has a "personal relationship" with you.

2. Delay acknowledging any serious problems with a "protected" component until you give another rave review to the "updated" model which replaces it and "corrects" the problems.

3. Avoid making any direct comparisons with a "protected" component, but if you have to, follow these "Solutions":

A. Compare the component only to older and/or obsolete models, especially from the same manufacturer. (See Rule #2 above).

B. If Solution "A" is not possible, compare the component to "competitors" costing either MUCH more or MUCH less.

C. If both Solutions "A" or "B" are not possible, "neglect" to mention the actual names and model numbers of the rival components that you compare it to in the review.

D. If Solutions "A", "B" or "C" are all not feasible, and you must compare the model to a current, similarly priced (and "protected") competitor that you must name, then you must be:

1. As ambiguous as possible, and you must also...
2. Never describe any problem as "serious" (See Rule #3.E)
3. Never proclaim one model to be clearly superior to the other(s). In short...
4. Both (or all) of the components must be seen as equally desirable and of similar value.

E. Problems or imperfections that aren't obvious (such as no bass below 40 Hz with small speakers), may be described as "serious" (easy to hear) only when using Solutions "A", "B" or "C".

However, any problems described when using Solution "D" must always be "subtle" and "difficult to hear", or even described as an "advancement" if possible.

4. You must never inform readers if an "audiophile" accessory or tweak is also available in a generic form at a fraction of the price that the "protected" manufacturer is charging (Blue Tac and RFI rings etc.).

5. Any and all "transactions" between you and any of the parties mentioned in Rule #1 must always be kept strictly Confidential. Accordingly...

A. You must never divulge the actual price, if any, you paid to "purchase" your reference components or accessories, or any extra costs you paid, if any, to have those same components updated, modified, repaired, replaced etc.

B. You must never divulge any "gifts", "favors" or "perks" that you received from the "protected" audio entities, or those with whom you have a "personal relationship".

6. You must never mention the actual costs, even at retail prices, of the parts that are used to manufacture the component.

7. Further to Rules #4 & #6, you must never state, or even imply, that any component or accessory is "over-priced".

8. The more corrupt your magazine is, the more you shall proclaim your honesty.

9. Magazines shall never divulge the actual percentage of their advertising revenues to their total revenues.

10. OVERRIDE CLAUSE- Some of the preceding rules (#1, #2 & #3) may be ignored only in the event of either a serious (and apparently indefinite) breach of the "personal relationship" between the audio company and reviewer/magazine, and/or the termination, or non-payment, of their advertising contract.

User avatar

Jorge E. López H.
Posts: 1950
Joined: 15 Jan 2011 04:03
Equipos: SISTEMA PRINCIPAL ESTEREO:
Front End:
Amplificador estado sólido Onkyo M-504
Amplificador a bulbos PrimaLuna Dialogue 5
Preamplificador a bulbos Primaluna Dialogue 3
Crossover Behringer CX-2310
Fuentes:
Reproductor CD/SACD estereo Marantz SA 15S2
Tornamesa J.A.Michell Gyrodec más control velocidad Gyro QC
Brazo Cleraudio Unify más pastilla Denon DL 103R
Pre de fono a bulbos DejaVu
Servidor de medios Olive 4HD (Para música)
Servidor de medios Dune HD Max (Para video)
Cassette Deck Pioneer CT-F700
Bocinas:
De rango completo Revel Performa F32

SISTEMA HT (5.1) acoplado a sistema estéreo
Receptor multicanal Yamaha RX-A2010
Reproductor BluRay Yamaha BDS671
Servidor de medios Dvico TViX Slim S1
Bocinas surround: Klipsch
Subwoofer: Velodyne 10

Re: THE (SECRET) RULES OF 'AUDIO REVIEWING'

#2

Post by Jorge E. López H. » 24 Sep 2013 14:08

Interesante. Refleja con exactitud lo que es el medio del HiEnd
""Are you gonna bark all day, little doggie, or are you gonna bite?" Mr. Blonde

User avatar

Valentin
Posts: 1812
Joined: 14 Jan 2011 17:28
Contact:

Re: THE (SECRET) RULES OF 'AUDIO REVIEWING'

#3

Post by Valentin » 24 Sep 2013 16:58

Falto una muy importante y es la que rige el hi fi/end

Las mediciones Objetivas no sirven ni representan la calidad de un componente ya que la musica es un arte y el arte no es medible

la opinion que importa es la de reviewer y dicho esto se guiara con las siguientes reglas secretas
Ciencia al Servicio del Arte
http://www.arquitecturaaural.com

Post Reply

Return to “Artí­culos y referencias técnicas”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest